Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-3076045-20140917182118/@comment-5988399-20140924191410

I don't think merging in one cases and keeping separated in another is a smart idea. Consistency is key, in my opinion. Whichever option you eventually decide, it should be the same on all subjects. Users will easily get confused to whether to add Solstheim (Bloodmoon), as to pick up on the example previously given, or Solstheim (Dragonborn), when pages like the Sweetroll are merged.

As I personally prefer not to have these kind of overflooding pages on the same subject, there would be indeed a decrease in the amount of pages, it'd be a lot of work to merge the pages and the information, as well as the pages getting fairly long and perhaps slightly less clear (though I think the latter is invalid, as there can be headings).

Nevertheless, keeping the pages separated has its own advantage, but then I think the pages should all be named consistently, as they are on the UESP. It's clear what to type in your URL bar if you wish to know something, which is an aspect this wiki lacks.

Sincerely, Yaell Novella (talk) 19:14, September 24, 2014 (UTC)