Board Thread:Consensus Track/@comment-3186827-20140708103950/@comment-26474238-20140709180154

Flightmare wrote: As you can see on my talk page, I prefer having a conversation in one place. It is far easier to find old conversations once they get archived. But personal tastes can differ by a large amount from user to user. Some users might simply find it too much work (or too hard to understand) to use either talkback templates or Watchlist talk pages. These reasons however, are not why I vote neutral. I think it is too difficult to enfoce such a rule. Patrolling talk pages for cross-talking is not an easy task. Simply deleting contributions is not the right approach, and moving messages is too much work.

Since I still have not received an answer, I see this as definitely being the largest issue with the forum: there are absolutely no propositions given on how this rule will be enforced. How will new users know about this rule? Will users be blocked over not using template:talk? And most importantly, how is this more beneficial to the wiki rather than harmful?

If someone is going to propose a change, then the community should be made aware of these diner details. As it is right now, all we have is a vague idea, with everyone mostly left in the dark on what will happen should this new rule pass.