Board Thread:Consensus track/@comment-4787430-20130809213148/@comment-3186827-20130823092001

Shockstorm wrote: Some I found:
 * Category:Solstheim Locations - include Dragonborn as well?
 * Category:Cities in Skyrim - include other games beside Arena?
 * I was working on Category:Skills and fixed most of the pages there, but I'm not sure if Mysticism and Restoration belong there. And technically I don't think Mining is a skill.

Looks like there's a lot of Oblivion and some Morrowind pages that have overarching categories that haven't been removed since the policy was updated. Looking at these:

Almost every cat like these should be prefixed by the game - that is the only way we can organize pages effectively over all games and not be confused to what a cat should be used for.
 * Category:Solstheim Locations - should really be part of Bloodmoon: Locations, following the convention for other game and not include Dragonborn.
 * Category:Cities in Skyrim - Should be renamed to Arena: Skyrim Locations or Arena: Skyrim Cities - and should not include other games beside Arena.

I'm not too hot on the idea of creating new categories for things like Dragonborn: Nords or Dawnguard: Dunmer - mainly because:

For spells, it makes sense to have Dragonborn: Spells or Shouts etc - there are enough for it to make sense.
 * Many cases the cat will contain 1 or 2 entries. Dragonborn has 1 new Orc character - Mogrul. Same for Ancarion - do we really want to create a new category for just him? - It's too specific to justify it.
 * What use is really for our readers (or editors) to list all Altmer NPCs in Dragonborn, for example.

I think the setup we have for the Skyrim add-ons works well for now - we should focus on going back to the older game categories and bringing them in line with Skyrim cats.