User blog comment:Zippertrain85/Dawnguard Follow up./@comment-17114085-20131216013719/@comment-9062114-20131220221149

1) It's pretty baseless to assume that it has some "Invisible barrier" around it. We would've heard about it if it truly existed. The Thalmor Embassy is actually quite a ways away from the castle, what would they do doing sailing around the Sea of Ghosts?

2) SKYRIM. High King of SKYRIM. According to you Skyrim didn't exist before Harald, Skyrim didn't exist. It was just a bunch of small Kingdoms.

3) She actually says in the questline how she never left the castle really.

2&3) They could've easily just used Human Cattle to do it. I fail to see how this is "proof".

4) Okay, you still don't understand what I'm saying, why didn't they colonize the land they followed them too? That was my original point, yet everytime I ask it, you avoid the question, so please answer it.

5) She doesn't know what they look like, she HEARD that they were Elves with beards. Showing that she doesn't know. She might've just said that as an observation, not because she didn't know they were gone. That's complete speculation on your part.