Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-10197675-20130806142227/@comment-24349111-20141218132726

OrcGodMalakath21 wrote:

Pelinal Whitestrake wrote:

OrcGodMalakath21 wrote: 89.245.238.71 wrote: Did Bethesda ever say that his stuff isn't canon? No. And as long as they don't say that, his writings can be considered canon. Besides, everyone has their own headcanon. Maybe it isn't canon for you , but it certainly is canon for me and many other people who enjoy the nice and deep things MK adds to the TES lore. And fact is that we wouldn't be talking about Numidium if it weren't for MK's 'fan-fiction'.

This is the original quote to which my original quote was a reply for. My point was not that kirkbride's writings are not at all canon but just the parts that were incorporated into the game, which, obviously, has occurred. My point essentially was that anyone, including you, me, Bo-Bo the clown, and Kirkbride, can say/write anything we want about TES lore, but until it is incorporated into the game itself, or otherwise stated by Bethesda, it can not be considered canon but rather fan-fiction.

Pelinal Whitestrake, was that post grammatically and punctuated correct enough for you? Much better than your previous posts, thank you very much.

And still, all things which I mentioned and about everything else which MK has written has been incorporated into a TES game, even the more complex things such as CHIM. You're still not making a point. from what I understand not all of his writings have been incorporated into the game. if this is false, I admit my ignorance. and im sorry. In some form, most of them have been, yes.