Board Thread:Consensus Track/@comment-3186827-20140708103950/@comment-3186827-20140712145524

SuperSajuuk wrote:

Kennyannydenny wrote: It being used all the time on Wikipedia, it works a lot better than having to switch between talk pages. That's not true. As stated by Jimeee, both methods are being used. Just because it's better doesn't make it the more appropriate method. Forcing people to adopt a template is silly and not enforceable. Let people use what method they want, especially taking into account that you will not get a notification if you do it the way being proposed by Jimeee. @SuperSajuuk, it's unnecessary to provide a rebuttal for every comment you disagree with. As I said, this CT is to raise awareness of the system. No one will forcing you to use the talk template or adopt the system. If others use a different system, there is no need to explain why they are "wrong".

Secondly, keep a cool head and don't make accusations about what people should or should not be doing. Its not only irrelevant to the CT, but presumptuous.

I'll close the comments now as pretty much all the pros and cons have been made and are clear at this point. It's up to users if they wish to adopt this system or ignore it.