Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-174.44.92.186-20140909202751/@comment-25038310-20140916150548

Datadragon Odahviing wrote: Lel, sorry, I messed up that one. Yup, he was defeated by Isildur, a man, then the couple of hobbits somehow made gollum drop into the lava and destroy the One Ring.

Which was unrealistic and suckked. Frodo was obsessed with the One ring right at the end, and the Gollum appeared. They fought over it and eventually fell. Frodo could still hold onto a rock while Golum fell right in the lava of Mount Doom.

What exactly sucked and what was unrealistic?