Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-49.149.241.33-20141101114751/@comment-2601:192:C201:9BA3:7D19:745C:2B65:1B1D-20171207155818

Ehh, Narfi seems to me like someone who was born mentally ill, and after losing his family he has nothing else to do other than drink. Sad, but harmless. Wilhelm I could go either way on, but I doubt he did it or he wouldn't tell you anything about her (that bit where he recites Narfi's lines is definitely a glitch, I couldn't get it to happen in my game at all. They must've switched voice actors or something like that and that's why the line is in there). However, I have a few ideas that don't involve either of them!

I think Reyda was either mauled by a nearby bear and the arrows are just another glitch, OR the hunter you run into on the way to high hrothgar killed her by accident (if it was night or snowing hard and she was bent over while foraging for plants, she could've been mistaken for an animal) and the hunter didn't want anyone to know and dumped her in the river. OR, if you still want that murder intrigue aspect, she was the hunter's lover and he caught her cheating with the (also mysteriously dead) wood cutter just outside town, and killed them both in a jealous rage. He staged the wood cutter's body to look like a random bandit or an animal attack, and then threw Reyda's body in the water.