User blog comment:Zelron/The Elder Scrolls V: Dragonborn rumors (Imbedded deep the secrets sleep)/@comment-4557996-20121020044700/@comment-4113369-20121020232705

You're not honestly trying to be logical and/or rational about the setting of TES, are you? It's high fantasy, the only reliable source for anything is whatever information we can get from Bethesda or the games themselves. Until its eventual retconning (which is annoyingly likely, given that it's Bethesda), I don't see any reason to doubt the Bloodmoon Prophecy. Logic doesn't always apply to fantasy, what with the presence of magic, gods, etc., not to mention the whole CHIM thing...