Board Thread:Consensus Track/@comment-1251315-20150307101537/@comment-13446185-20150308030441

SuperSajuuk: wrote I wouldn't say it's too much an issue, as that is only primarily for the small meta description. If a regular editor clicked through the link, they would see what any other would see (unless they were dumb enough to disable javascript in their browsers xD). Well then what exactly do you mean by "search engines will simply render a blank page", it sounds like you're saying that the tabview would mess with how search engines link the pages, which would certainly be a big problem.

Personally, the template method looks a bit out of place and draws my attention too easily (especially as that was generally just an experimental test and never fully discussed). Well, I imagine that could be changed somehow. Though, isn't it kind of a good thing that it draws attention? We wouldn't want people missing the thing if it were to be implemented.

AutoBlood wrote: I like the idea of making base disambiguation pages into lore pages and containing links to other pages based on the games within them. But I dislike pages like M'aiq the Liar because I believe it looks messier and more unorganized, while separate pages for each game is a much better way to go. I don't see how it looks unorganized, all it does is add a little tab at the top which allows you to quickly look through each game's info on the character. They're still pretty much how separate pages would appear, just a bit closer togethor.