Board Thread:Consensus Track/@comment-3186827-20140708103950/@comment-1251315-20140708122219

Dovahsebrom wrote: reasons stated above.

I would honestly be fine with a message wall. While I do see the advantages in talk pages, message walls seem more organized, though I really hate how unecessarily big the messages are.

Is there anyway we could have both a talk page and a message wall? If Message Walls are implemented, they replace the user talkpages with a threaded conversation system similar to forum threads. They can't both exist.

@Jimeee: Talkpages are not meant for that, they're just for quick 1-1 discussions between a user and someone else (eg admin reminding user of policies, or admin asking about a specific edit by a specific user). Extensive conversation about an edit on an article belongs on the talkpage of an article.