Board Thread:Consensus Track/@comment-658634-20131216220021/@comment-658634-20131217182611

DarthOrc wrote: No, no, a thousand times no! They have not split up the Civilization, Borderlands  or Fallout Wikis up for a reason: people who play one game in a series often play (or contemplate playing) others and it is much more convient to have all the games on one site. You are making a quite big leap of faith making that kind of assumption. I have all civilizations (and their extension) in my shelf, I have also all Fallout's (except that wannabee tactics), M&M's, BF's, Deus Ex's, JA's, Sim's (with most extension), Orion's, HL's, Ultima's, BG's, HOMM's, Diablo's and I don't use any of the combination wikis. Hence stop making assumption of all using them and state that you are guessing. Side of that no, its not convenient to have them all in one wiki. Specially when transition from wiki to wiki is done so easily as w:c: hyperlink prefix. They contain either misleading information, irrelevant information, are filled with pages that are created because some other game has same named article, requires pages containing 6 in case of ES or as many as 13(!) subsections for each of the games or creating six same named articles with suffix, templates need take account other games, and so on.

The cons are numerous, they rise their head each time you need to specify about what game you are handling, so please give me some hard pros if come up any.