Board Thread:Lore Discussion/@comment-25588920-20141217173225/@comment-213.73.25.172-20180319172842

There are maaaany different factors.

If you are mad or worship Sheogorath he will always find a way to claim your soul if he wants to. (Like he did with son of Malacath)

Sometimes your soul is split into pieces for everyone.

Also, Hircine claims Werewolfes, Molag Bal vampires, Sheogorath madmen, Malacath orcs etc.

If you stopped worshipping a prince and started to worship someone else, the first one loses his rights for your soul.