FANDOM


(Created page with "A bit more about why the 3rd option is "Put all versions of the book to one page":<br /> If we decide that content differences don't qualify for the book to have a separate ar...")
 
 
Line 1: Line 1:
 
A bit more about why the 3rd option is "Put all versions of the book to one page":<br />
 
A bit more about why the 3rd option is "Put all versions of the book to one page":<br />
 
If we decide that content differences don't qualify for the book to have a separate article, then even if the book has completely different contents but still has the same (or almost the same) name or parts of the text, it is added to the hub book article.<br />
 
If we decide that content differences don't qualify for the book to have a separate article, then even if the book has completely different contents but still has the same (or almost the same) name or parts of the text, it is added to the hub book article.<br />
A bit of "reductio ad absurdum" to show that we either accept the 2nd point and follow the SF to the word or accept the 3rd point and either be inconsistent or make long hub articles for logically different books.
+
A bit of "reductio ad absurdum" to show that we either accept the 2nd point and follow the SF to the word or accept the 3rd point and either be inconsistent and subjective or make long hub articles for logically different books.

Latest revision as of 10:07, October 6, 2019

A bit more about why the 3rd option is "Put all versions of the book to one page":
If we decide that content differences don't qualify for the book to have a separate article, then even if the book has completely different contents but still has the same (or almost the same) name or parts of the text, it is added to the hub book article.
A bit of "reductio ad absurdum" to show that we either accept the 2nd point and follow the SF to the word or accept the 3rd point and either be inconsistent and subjective or make long hub articles for logically different books.

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.