Third Possibility[]
It's possible to get Camilla to hate both of them by talking to one, telling the other about the false letter, and then pickpocketing the letter he takes. You'll have both letters at that point and can tell her about both of them. Gets you nothing really, but Faendal will still follow you.65.175.176.184 15:37, October 4, 2012 (UTC)
New message[]
You can tell the truth, marry her, buy it back, and lie about it, and she'll still believe the lie.
Not sure if the liar or the rejected rewards you, yet. Papayaman1000 (talk) 07:15, August 2, 2016 (UTC)
Faendal's death?[]
I have twice returned to Riverwind to find Faendal dead. I did not kill him and I have not received messages from the courier. In one, I talked to Faendal and delivered his message directly to Camilla. In the second I talked to Sven, then to Faendal and delivered Faendal's letter to Camilla. I had not seen this before. 63.228.142.80 22:18, December 10, 2016 (UTC)